I know One Battle After Another was ordained on its release as one of the best films of the century (despite us not knowing what the next 75 years will bring) and is the chosen film to win all the Oscars and other awards that will line up to be bestowed this year. It features some talented actors giving rather competent and impressive performances over its epic runtime. Finally it is written and directed by a film maker deemed by film discourse to be one of the greatest white male directors working today.
That's all fine. I admit One Battle After Another is a well crafted film made by people who know how to make movies. Art is subjective. People who like this film are just as right to like it as anyone who doesn't. When films like this come out I am reminded about just how personal the experience of enjoying films is because while I can appreciate intellectually why someone would enjoy this film, One Battle After Another just didn't come together for me in the way it does for the film bros.
Early into the story, it is clear Anderson in interested (as he often is) in an irreverence that is popular in this style of film making but always takes me out of these films. Anderson's humour keeps himself and his audience at a distance from his subject. I struggle with this sort of film making approach at it makes it feel like we're "tool cool" to invest ourselves in the story's emotional core. We don't have to connect fully with the issues or characters and can be detached in a way that lets us remain above it all. This sort of style, which is quite popular amongst a certain part of cinema, makes it hard for me to invest myself in these stories. The film leans heavily into the humour and for me this is like a safeguard that means the audience can sit and laugh instead of having to truly wrestle with the story's implications.
Some of what makes it not a total disappointment for me is how some of the cast overcomes this, specifically Chase Infiniti who feels (more than the higher profile male stars of this film) to be living into her role quite authentically and honestly. For me Penn and DiCaprio are playing caricatures whose dialogue often falls into stereotypes. But Infiniti brings a grounding to the story that invited me in. Hall often gets here too. But the film keeps trying to make everything light and breezy enough that we can have fun with topics that should be far more disconcerting than the movie makes them.
Everything about One Battle After Another's story crosses into almost parody. From the revolutionaries to the fascists, everything is a cartoon version of real life to be laughed at, not to be feared, sympathized with, or despised. Whenever the film's villains are on screen, a rather lampoonish group of white supremacists, they are treated as a joke. Instead of being menacing and evil they are almost comic relief. Even their final act of terror is played in a sort of anti-climactic manner. The revolutionaries are often presented as laughable stereotypes as well, even if they are more likeable, they remain, rather unreal. Because it's all just pretend and never feels real, even down to all the silly names every character has. Again I think this is done so a certain audience can feel comfortable watching it instead of contending with it.
I get why some of the themes this movie is wrapping its story around would be difficult for many and might take away from the fun. But for me it also took away from the emotional resonance and the connection I had to the tale. The final emotional moments did not feel earned for me. So while I get why someone would enjoy this film and I am in no way saying it's a bad movie (whatever that means) I am just saying it didn't work for me. And that's quite disappointing as there is a story here that I would probably respond to quite favourably if it were in the hands of a different director with a different style of film making. At its heart One Battle After Another is about our choices and their consequences, and what real family actually means. Normally I'd be eating this stuff up. But here I felt little nothing.
One Battle After Another will likely be showered with awards and be named on all sorts of "best" lists. But I do wonder how many of its devotees will watch it over and over returning to its story and characters repeatedly, as it rings of the kind of film that people say they love but only ever watch once.
One Battle After Another
Starring: Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Benicio del Toro, Regina Hall, Teyana Taylor, Chase Infiniti, Alana Haim, Tony Goldwyn, Jena Malone
Writer/Director: Paul Thomas Anderson