Deadwyler is becoming one of my favourite actors to watch these days. The Woman in the Yard, while it has some weaknesses, is a great showcase for her. There is a moment near the end where she broke my heart in a very short yet powerful scene.
It is hard not to talk about The Woman in the Yard without spoiling it so before getting into those sorts of details, I'll say Collet-Serra's work her is a bit all over the place. He makes some effective tensions and scary bits but also drags the story in certain parts. A versatile direction of action and horror his work isn't always the most emotionally invested and this film needed more tender loving care with that aspect. But the fact that Deadwyler is centred here makes up for some of that loss.
In the end The Woman in the Yard is less scary than emotionally moving so while the film does have some jump scares and some fear inducing images, the real meat here is in Deadwyler's character and her journey. Together her performance with Collet-Serra's horror aesthetic makes it quite watchable. While I think the emotional punch at the end is weaker than it could have been it remains an interesting story and character arc.
The Woman in the Yard is old school classic horror. Collet-Serra sets up who the characters are and what the threat is pretty quickly and effectively and dives into the story. Here is where he gets a bit shaky though. Once the story gets rolling it lurches a bit. When all is "revealed" some of that lurching makes sense but it would have worked best is that uneven tone was given some in story reason as well so it doesn't just feel off. Some of Collet-Serra's most impressionist takes here aren't smoothly done. But he does pull it together at the end, again with much of the heavy lifting done by Deadwyler.
*Spoilers*
The Woman in the Yard is powerful in how it anthropomorphizes depression in classic horror tropes. The story is about a mother and her children dealing with her own self-harm impulses. That is a devastating concept, and yet one so real for many people. The horror genre allows for a means to process some of that. For the most part I felt The Woman in the Yard managed this well yet the ending just felt a little to pat. I had wished he found a way to sit with that pain for a bit and really let us experience it and the path out of it. I get where the film is going with its stuffy symbolizing (as it was foreshadowed) caring for each other, but Collet-Serra rushes this a bit. Deadwyler is amazing and she could have really had an incredible moment. As I said early on here she still broke my heart, but there is a bit of a missed opportunity.
Still I'd recommend this. It is the kind of film that is interesting to discuss afterward. Finding ways to represent difficult emotional states on film is one of the reasons why cinema can be so satisfying.
The Woman in the Yard
Starring: Danielle Deadwyler, Okwui Okpokwasili, Russell Hornsby, Peyton Jackson, Estella Kahiha
Director: Jaume Collet-Serra
Writer: Sam Stefanak