I've seen all of the films nominated for Oscars in the five short film categories in 2025 and I noticed some trends. For example in the animation stop motion was strong this year (which might be my favourite animation style). While in the live action films it was noticeable that all but one of the film was based on real events whether they ended up being highly fictionalized or a direct adaptation of real events. There were some inspiring documentaries this year, a category that often leaves more sadness than hope. Here are my thoughts on this year's crop of Oscar nominated short films.
Animation
Beautiful Men
Stop motion holds a special place in my heart and this year a few of the nominees were stop motion films including this one about three brothers on a trip to Istanbul for hair transplants. It quite entertainingly and rather frankly explores men's body issues connected to aging and societal expectations. While being very funny it is also surprisingly insightful and moving with charming animation.
Magic Candies
My favourite of this year's animated nominees has the most gorgeous stop motion animation and a sweet and poignant story about a little boy eating candies which open his mind to the world around him. I found the movie truly moving and utterly relatable. It is the sort of film that anyone of all ages can appreciate. Its story is lovely and will put a big smile on your face.
In the Shadow of Cypress
This traditionally drawn animated film packs a lot into its story runtime as an estranged daughter and father attempt to rescue a beached whale. The animation is simple but beautiful and the story is intense. Dialogue free it relies on images to convey a lot. Sometimes I felt it didn't all connect but overall it is a powerful movie.
Yuck!
This is the funniest and most purely delightful of this crop of animated films. When a group of children see adults kissing at a campground, they are fascinated but disgusted... until they aren't. The stylized 2D animation is adorable and captures the film's sense of whimsy.
Wander to Wonder
This film at its heart is about grieving and loss told through an absurdist story. It's complicated narrative is remarkably conveyed in the film's short runtime. A mix of stop motion and live action, the film captures something quite profound while also pushing some boundaries.
Live Action
A Lien
This film is very timely in how it focuses on deportation and the tactics American authorities use to take people into custody while they are applying through legal channels for their citizenship. Short but powerful, A Lien is emotionally charged and kinetically filmed. It's title, a play on words, highlights the themes of the story.
Anuja
Anuja's choice to cast a street involved young actor as the star of this emotionally charged film makes it even more powerful. This is a Sophie's Choice style story about the impossibilities faced by those in the lowest economic circumstances. Despite how heavy the story is the film has a joyousness to it which is uplifting.
I'm Not a Robot
The only truly fictional film nominated in this category this year, I'm Not a Robot is a hilarious yet quite dark story that examines identity and agency in a very of-the-moment way. The idea isn't unique (it's the subject of the contemporaneous American film Companion as well as the classic Blade Runner) but the structure of this short film manages it exceptionally during its brief runtime.
The Last Ranger
This is the most epic in scope of the films nominated. The story, based on real events, is broken down in a very effective and emotionally satisfying way. The reality of this story hits hard and the young star gives an incredible performance.
The Man Who Could Not Remain Silent
A tense political thriller boiled down to 20 minutes. It centres you in the story with its intimate cinematography and high stakes. Silent is based on real events but told in a way that can be related to in any time, perhaps especially now.
Documentaries
Death By Numbers
Focusing on the high profile sentencing hearing of the Parkland shooter, from the point of view of one of the survivors, this film wrestles quite powerfully with the impossibility of finding resolution after such a horrible event. This isn't the only film nominated this year that touches on themes connected to the death penalty nor brutal murders. There is a recognition here of the strength needed to live on after events that have no possibility of resolution.
I Am Ready, Warden
This film also tackles the issue of capital punishment, this time from multiple points of view, including but not limited to the adult child of a murder victim and the teen child of the murderer. There is a powerful moment near the end when the realization that death doesn't bring about justice or peace which shakes its audience to its core.
Incident
Incident is quite simply a collection of actual "found footage" (from security cameras, police body cams, and other filmed records) recording the events of a police shooting of an innocent man in real time. However there is nothing simple about it. It is brutal to watch and overwhelming to take in the gravity of how these crimes can occur. The film's sparse approach to presenting the film and letting us see the "incident" with our own eyes, is likely more powerful than it would have been if the film had taken a more narrative approach.
Instruments of a Beating Heart
This is one of two more charming films that don't focus on tragedy. Beating Heart follows young grade school children in Japan as they practice for an orchestral performance of Ode to Joy and the film is rather joyous. There is a part in the middle that western audiences might find a bit unsettling, when a teacher sternly berates one of the 6 year olds for her failure to practice. But the film pivots from that quickly to instead focus on how much the children enjoy performing together for their peers and parents.
The Only Girl in the Orchestra
The most cinematic of the bunch, this film maker has made a tribute to her favourite aunt, a woman who inspired her and lived a rich and full life doing what she loves. Orin O'Brien was the first woman in the NY Philharmonic and her pursuit of her passion is a wonderful thing to see. Molly O'Brien has made a wonderful film that celebrates her inspirational family member and celebrates a life well lived. That's not a bad way to end this round of short films.