Much has been said about how visually striking del Toro's long awaited adaptation of the legendary science fiction novel is. From the art direction to the make up to the visual effects, Frankenstein is a glorious spectacle that is incredible to watch. Is this ironic as it will most often be enjoyed on the smaller screen due to its release being focused on streaming? Perhaps. But regardless del Toro, as with so many of his films, delivers cinema in all its beautiful, visual opulence.
But the source material contains multitudes. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is literature that has sparked the imagination for centuries and inspired so much discussion. It is rich with ideas that remains incredibly relevant to audiences over time. Often adaptations of this work are unable to capture the complexity of all that. I believe there are ways del Toro has managed to translate some of that to the screen but in ways that often feel heavy handed, embedded in what is his monster movie.
His approach has never been one of subtlety. del Toro invites us into his discussion quite blatantly. The script works in references to the themes of the tale in overt ways, eg. someone calls Victor "Prometheus" as a jab and Victor's lab is in a tower that is obviously phallic. His script has people speaking the point of the scene verbally, often quite literally. He says the quiet part out loud. If you're looking for subtext, this isn't your film, but I never felt this approach sacrificed the moralities for the enjoyment of the story.
del Toro inserts Shelley herself into the film, but not in the literal way Whale did in the classic Bride of Frankenstein. He has altered the character of Elizabeth to be a rather blunt stand in for the author. So much of Shelley's point is a critque of male ambition and she is here to voice that. While I often find Goth's performances rather wooden, and that's not much different here, she does actively give perspective to the critique of what is going on.
The film allows time for something that is often missing in these adaptations, time for Victor to revel in his "success" before, after attempting to exercise his control and fails, then turns on the "monster" he creates.
This Victor is far more a straight up villain that we usually see. We see how his abusive father crafts him into an abusive adult himself. He is a fountain of arrogance and ambition who blames others for his mistakes. And he is cruel. Yes the film gives him some reasons to be, but still holds him accountable for his own cruelty.
del Toro presents his version as body horror. He focuses on the gore of the body, something this story is quite open to exploiting. The questions of morality are tied very much to the physical realities of mankind and how those are tied to our souls or our intellects or however you wish to understand it. I know there are critics who eschew the physicality and fetishization of the scientific tropes to be "missing the point" of Shelley's writing, but for me it creates a grounding in just how horrific it is. It is one thing to discuss the morality from an intellectual standpoint, but that can ignore the human experience of it.
Like of a lot of del Toro's films, there is an almost cartoony fantastic feel to Frankenstein. Elordi's creature never feels quite real but that doesn't take away from how successfully he imbues the creature with humanity. This film is bombastic and bold. And it's likely longer than it needs to be. It is in your face, holding your hand to ensure you get the point, and that will not be to everyone's taste. del Toro wears his passions on his sleeve and he clearly is passionate about this story and tells it with a relish that is delicious.
Frankenstein is a delightful watch even if its approach is on the spectacular and rather obvious side. I'd say del Toro is mostly successful in capturing the spark that gives this legend so much life.
Frankenstein
Starring: Oscar Isaac, Jacob Elordi, Mia Goth, Christoph Waltz, Lars Mikkelsen, Felix Kammerer, David Bradley, Charles Dance, Burn Gorman
Writer/Director: Guillermo del Toro
No comments:
Post a Comment