Did a movie's ending ever piss you off so much it ruins the movie for you generally? That's kinda what happened for me with Eternity a movie I was generally enjoying up to the last 20 minutes.
The premise, in the afterlife you get to pick an eternity, but only one, that you get to spend... well, eternity in. When a woman dies she finds that both her first husband (who died in a war long ago) and her second husband, who she lived with for decades until both their deaths, are in the afterlife both waiting to spend eternity with her.
The movie does a really great job of setting up its central problem; that she has to pick which of them to spend eternity with. It sets out very well that her love for both of them is very real and that each is different but both fully love. The film's plot even gets the husbands, who begin the story seeing each other as competitors for some sort of prize, to the point where they understand what the other meant to her and begin to feel grateful to the other for the role they played in the life of the woman they loved.
So far so good. In addition the script is rather funny and clever, Early and Randolph are more than delightful, and the three leads bring just the right mix of humour and pathos to their roles. There was an awkward pedophilia joke in there that should ended up on the cutting room floor but mostly the script is tight. I really appreciated how well the script makes the complications of this set up feel so real and nuanced. Untill...
*Spoilers*
Eternity, up until it's third act seems to be making the case that the problem is the having to choose, but the final act switches this kinda out of no where. After spending most of its runtime showing us exactly why both her relationships were meaningful and had worth, at the end she very quickly decides that the one (her first husband) just didn't cut the mustard and that she has to choose the second husband. There is no build up to this. Nothing in the character development does anything to imply that her first love wasn't as rich and meaningful as the second. Yet the film just feels fine throwing all that away so that there can be a "winner" and a "loser" or at least a resolution that is comfortable. The final moments play out like a prototypical rom-com with the whole running against time to catch the leaving lover before it's too late shtick instead of the clever quirky film it had been attempting to be up til then.
Maybe I had hoped too much from a Hollywood comedy. I had hoped the film would present that she, as a fully realized human being, could have a complicated set of emotions and, since it is effin eternity, the time to pursue and explore all the love that she has with the men she loves. But no. I had aimed too high for this sort of thing.
So yeah, what was originally a fun film with an interesting idea and a great cast that I would recommend to people for a smart and funny watch, ended up being enough of a disappointment I would likely tell people to skip it altogether.
Eternity
Starring: Miles Teller, Elizabeth Olsen, Callum Turner, John Early, Olga Merediz, Da'Vine Joy Randolph, Betty Buckley, Barry Primus
Director: David Freyne
Writer: Pat Cunnane, David Freyne
No comments:
Post a Comment